| Name | BHS Class | Sport | School/Team | Level |
| Tucker Barnhart | 2009 | Baseball | Cincy Reds Minor League System | Professional |
| T.J. Baumet | 2007 | Baseball | Ball State | NCAA-DI |
| Lauren Baumet | 2010 | Women's Volleyball | St. Louis | NCAA-DI |
| Alex Berlyn | 2008 | Baseball | DePauw | NCAA-DIII |
| David Birrer | 2007 | Men's Swimming & Diving | Wabash | NCAA-DIII |
| Molly Birrer | 2010 | Women's Swimming & Diving | Hillsdale | NCAA-DII |
| Michael Bradburn | 2007 | Baseball | Indiana Tech | NAIA |
| Jeremy Brading | 2006 | Men's Track & Field | Kent State | NCAA-DI |
| Erin Brewer | 2008 | Women's Soccer | Milligan | NAIA |
| Rachael Brown | 2009 | Women's Volleyball | Southern Illinois | NCAA-DI |
| Mitchell Burton | 2009 | Baseball | Indiana Tech | NAIA |
| MacKenzie Calvert | 2010 | Women's Soccer | St. Joseph's | NCAA-DII |
| Adam Carlson | 2009 | Men's Soccer | Rose-Hulman | NCAA-DIII |
| Michael Caruso | 2010 | Men's Soccer | Franklin | NCAA-DIII |
| Madison Cleveland | 2010 | Football | Kentucky Wesleyan College | NCAA-DII |
| Julia Collins | 2009 | Women's Swimming & Diving | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Jayme Comer | 2008 | Football | Illinois State | NCAA-DI |
| Mark Conover | 2008 | Baseball | Indiana Tech | NAIA |
| Amanda Davidson | 2001 | Women's Basketball | BC Pharmaserv Marburg | Professional |
| Alexis DeJean | 2007 | Women's Track & Field | St. Joseph's | NCAA-DII |
| Kurtis Drake | 2008 | Football | Marian | NAIA |
| Matt Duncan | 2009 | Baseball | Southeastern | NJCAA-DII |
| Nicole Duncan | 2010 | Women's Soccer | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Josh Elkins | 2008 | Men's Cross-Country/Men's Track & Field | Rose-Hulman | NCAA-DIII |
| Chris Estridge | 2008 | Men's Soccer | Indiana | NCAA-DI |
| Kelsee Evans | 2008 | Women's Volleyball | Marian | NAIA |
| Leah Freestone | 2010 | Women's Basketball | DePauw | NCAA-DIII |
| Tyler Fritcha | 2008 | Men's Soccer | IUPUI | NCAA-DI |
| Rachel Fulkerson | 2010 | Women's Soccer | Indiana Wesleyan | NAIA |
| Zach Harrison | 2008 | Baseball | Indiana Tech | NAIA |
| Ian Hatleli | 2008 | Men's Soccer | Millikan | NCAA-DIII |
| Gordon Hayward | 2008 | Men's Basketball | Utah Jazz | Professional |
| Robby Hechinger | 2009 | Baseball | Wabash | NCAA-DIII |
| Michael Heinekamp | 2010 | Men's Tennis | Bellarmine | NCAA-DII |
| Carolyn Holstein | 2007 | Women's Volleyball | Missouri-St. Louis | NCAA-DII |
| Micaela Hornstein | 2007 | Women's Soccer | Morehead State | NCAA-DI |
| Mikyla Houston | 2010 | Women's Track & Field | Anderson | NCAA-DIII |
| Mika Jackson | 2007 | Women's Soccer | Marian | NAIA |
| Mitch Jankowski | 2008 | Baseball/Men's Basketball | Ashford | NAIA-DII |
| Chris Jones | 2009 | Football | Bowling Green | NCAA-DI |
| Valerie Jones | 2008 | Women's Swimming & Diving | Evansville | NCAA-DI |
| Darryl Jordan | 2010 | Football | St. Joseph's | NCAA-DII |
| Gary King | 2006 | Baseball | Indiana Tech | NAIA |
| Jeffrey King | 2009 | Baseball | Indiana Tech | NAIA |
| Kristen Krauss | 2009 | Cheerleading | Butler | NCAA-DI |
| Zach Laffin | 2009 | Men's Swimming & Diving | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Abby Lawrence | 2007 | Cheerleading | Indiana | NCAA-DI |
| Lance Lynn | 2005 | Baseball | Memphis Redbirds | Professional |
| Kayla Lyttle | 2010 | Women's Soccer | Indiana Wesleyan | NAIA |
| Lisa MacAllister | 2007 | Women's Bowling | Sam Houston State | NCAA-DI |
| Nowell Mallory | 2009 | Football | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Julian Mavunga | 2008 | Men's Basketball | Miami (OH) | NCAA-DI |
| Jeff McClure | 2007 | Football | Marian | NAIA |
| Alex McGowan | 2010 | Baseball | Parkland | NJCAA-DII |
| Shane McNally | 2009 | Men's Soccer | St. Joseph's | NCAA-DII |
| Nicki Meidinger | 2010 | Softball | Grace | NAIA |
| Stephanie Meyer | 2009 | Women's Basketball | Danville Area | NJCAA-DII |
| Leslie Meyer | 2009 | Women's Soccer | MIT | NCAA-DIII |
| Haley Miller | 2009 | Women's Soccer/Women's Track & Field | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Drew Mitchell | 2009 | Men's Soccer | St. Joseph's | NCAA-DII |
| Kenya Owens | 2009 | Women's Track & Field | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Alan Paddock | 2010 | Men's Soccer/Men's Track & Field | Marian | NAIA |
| Claire Partlow | 2010 | Women's Swimming & Diving | SCAD | NAIA |
| Taylor Paton | 2008 | Women's Soccer | St. Mary's | NCAA-DIII |
| Stefanie Percival | 2007 | Cheerleading | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Kelsey Pritchard | 2008 | Women's Volleyball | Taylor | NAIA |
| Rhea Proctor | 2009 | Women's Soccer | IPFW | NCAA-DI |
| Colleen Rader | 2008 | Women's Swimming & Diving | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Nick Ramsey | 2007 | Football | Wabash | NCAA-DIII |
| Stephanie Rex | 2010 | Women's Volleyball | Lipscomb | NCAA-DI |
| Shawn Shupperd | 2009 | Football | Eastern Kentucky | NCAA-DI |
| Carl Smith | 2007 | Men's Track & Field | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Yogi Snyder | 2008 | Men's Soccer | IUPUI | NCAA-DI |
| Ceciley Starkey | 2007 | Women's Tennis | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Zack Stivers | 2007 | Men's Soccer | Valparaiso | NCAA-DI |
| Tori Stone | 2009 | Women's Track & Field | Indiana State | NCAA-DI |
| Drew Storen | 2007 | Baseball | Washington Nationals | Professional |
| Casey Stouder | 2010 | Women's Soccer | Marian | NAIA |
| Joel Stucker | 2010 | Baseball | Parkland | NJCAA-DII |
| Lauren Taylor | 2008 | Women's Basketball | New Mexico | NCAA-DI |
| Katelyn Tillotson | 2007 | Softball | St. Mary of the Woods | USCAA |
| Charles Torwudzo | 2010 | Football | Purdue | NCAA-DI |
| Katy Toth | 2008 | Women's Soccer | Marian | NAIA |
| Jacque Toth | 2008 | Women's Soccer | Illinois State | NCAA-DI |
| Scott Vicenzi | 2010 | Men's Cross-Country | Purdue | NCAA-DI |
| Kyle Waggoner | 2007 | Baseball | Butler | NCAA-DI |
| Allison Weimer | 2009 | Women's Track & Field | Bowling Green | NCAA-DI |
| Dalton Wentz | 2010 | Baseball | Florida Atlantic | NCAA-DI |
| Pat West | 2008 | Men's Soccer | Wabash | NCAA-DIII |
| Haley Wittig | 2010 | Women's Cross-Country | Indianapolis | NCAA-DII |
| Thomas Wood | 2009 | Football | Marian | NAIA |
| Jordan Woods | 2008 | Women's Golf | IUPUI | NCAA-DI |
| Bailey Yeager | 2009 | Women's Volleyball | Southern Illinois | NCAA-DI |
| Jessica Young | 2010 | Women's Soccer | Anderson | NCAA-DIII |